Estimated read time: 5 minutes

Your organic traffic may have dropped after Google's latest algorithm update because the update changed how Google ranks pages for your queries. It may also have dropped for a reason that happened at the same time. Google lists six kinds of causes for a Search traffic drop: algorithmic updates, technical issues, security issues, spam issues, seasonality and changing interests, and site moves. A drop that lines up with an update is a reason to investigate, not proof of the cause. The steps below separate the possibilities.

Take an illustrative case: a pediatric therapy practice in Northwest Arkansas sees fewer visits from Google in mid-November and reads that an update is rolling out. Before it rewrites a single page, it checks what changed, when, and where.

1. Know exactly which update, and whether it has finished

On November 17, 2026, Google's Search Status Dashboard listed the November 2026 core update as starting on November 10, 2026, with no completion recorded. It was still rolling out on the day this was checked.

The most recent spam update on the same dashboard was the September 2026 spam update. It started on September 24, 2026 and is listed with a duration of 13 days and 16 hours. The core update before November's started on May 21, 2026.

Google describes core updates as "broad in nature," changes that "don't target specific sites or individual web pages." It also recommends "waiting at least a full week after a core update completes" before analyzing a site in Search Console.

The action: open the dashboard and write down the start date and status of every update in the months your traffic changed. You know it worked when your traffic chart and the update dates sit side by side on one page.

2. Compare like with like in Search Console

Google's guidance on traffic drops recommends setting the Performance report to the last 16 months to see whether a drop repeats each year. A practice that slows every holiday season is looking at seasonality, not a penalty.

Then use the Compare option. Google suggests comparing recent months against the previous period or the same period last year. For a core update specifically, it suggests comparing a week after the update with the week before it began.

The action: set the report to 16 months and look for the same dip a year earlier. You know it worked when you can say whether this drop is new or recurring.

3. Find where the drop is concentrated

A sitewide drop and a drop on three pages are different problems. Google notes that site-wide technical issues usually cause sharper drops than page-level ones. Its guidance recommends breaking the Performance report down by query, page, country, device and search type.

Check the reports Google names alongside: Page indexing, Crawl stats, Security Issues and Manual Actions. A manual action or a security warning is a specific finding with a specific fix. A core update is not, and Google states that pages that move down "aren't necessarily bad."

There is one more pattern to look for. If impressions hold steady while clicks fall, Google points to the page title and snippet as worth reviewing.

The action: filter by page and list the ten pages that lost the most clicks. You know it worked when you can say whether the loss is spread across the site or concentrated in a few pages.

Listen to the audio version

4. Respond in proportion to what you found

Google's advice scales with the size of the drop. For small changes, it says "there's no need to take drastic action," and recommends avoiding radical changes to a page already performing well. For large, sustained drops, it recommends an honest review of the whole site for helpful, reliable content.

Google is also plain about timing. Some changes take effect in a few days. Others can take several months to register, and sometimes not until the next core update. Improvements are not guaranteed to produce a visible result.

The action: write one sentence that names the cause you can support with evidence and the change you will make because of it. If you cannot write that sentence, the evidence is not there yet. Wait for the update to complete and look again.

5. Check the same pages for AI answers

Google's AI features start from the same requirement as Search. Google states that a page is eligible as a supporting link in AI Overviews or AI Mode when it is indexed and eligible to show with a snippet. It also states that traffic from those features is counted in the Performance report under the Web search type, so your report already includes it.

That makes the investigation above an AI visibility check too. A page that lost its place in Google's index has lost its place in Google's AI features with it.

The action: run your three most important pages through the URL Inspection tool. You know it worked when each one reports it is on Google, which Google defines as eligible to appear, not guaranteed to.

An update changes how Google weighs pages. Being found still depends on what it always did: pages that can be indexed, read and trusted to answer the question.

This article contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission if you purchase through them, at no additional cost to you.

Stay in touch

Keep Reading